Reputation Management for Local Businesses: The 9 Best Resources

As a local business owner, your online reputation is one of your most valuable assets.

Today customers are more likely to research a business online before making a purchase or visiting an establishment.

This means that your online reputation can significantly impact your ability to get customers in the door and retain them. In fact, studies have shown that over 90% of customers read online reviews before making a purchase decision.

Managing your online reputation is critical to your business’s success. A positive online reputation can help you attract more customers, while a negative one can turn potential buyers away.

With the rise of social media and review sites like Yelp and Google Reviews, it’s easier than ever for customers to leave feedback about their interactions with your business. This means that it’s essential for you to actively manage your online reputation and respond to reviews in a timely and professional manner.

Diagram illustrating the steps involved in creating an effective reputation management plan for small businesses.

But reputation management isn’t just about responding to negative reviews. It’s also about proactively building a positive online presence for your business.

By providing excellent customer service, optimizing your website for search engines, and leveraging social media and review sites, you can build a strong reputation that attracts more customers and makes your business stand out.

In this blog post, we’ll explore nine resources that help you manage your local business’s online reputation, from your Google Business Profile (aka Google My Business) to industry-specific sites and online reputation management services like ReputationStacker.

But first, a little bit of background…

Understanding Reputation Management

Visual guide on how small shops can leverage online business reputation management to attract more customers.

What is Reputation Management?

Reputation management is the process of monitoring, maintaining, and improving a business’s online reputation.

It involves managing online reviews, social media, and other online platforms to build trust and credibility with customers.

Effective online reputation management is crucial for small businesses to stay competitive and attract new customers.

By actively engaging with customer feedback and addressing concerns, businesses can foster a positive online presence that reflects their commitment to quality and customer satisfaction.

Why is Reputation Management Important for Local Businesses?

Flowchart illustrating the customer journey and its impact on a small business's reputation management efforts.

Reputation management is essential for local businesses because it directly impacts how prospective customers perceive the business.

A strong online reputation can increase customer retention and loyalty, while a poor reputation can drive customers away and harm the business’s bottom line.

By managing their online reputation, local businesses can build trust with customers, increase their online visibility, and stay competitive in their industry.

These days online reviews and social media play a significant role in consumer decision-making. Maintaining a positive online reputation is more important than ever.

Now here are the best resources at your disposal for online reputation management for local businesses…

1. Google My Business

Google Business Profile is a free tool that allows business owners to manage their business information on Google.

By claiming and verifying and optimizing your Google Business Profile you can ensure that your business information is accurate and up-to-date on Google Search and Google Maps.

You can also respond to Google reviews and post updates to your listing, which can help improve the online reputation of your business and attract more customers.

For more tips, check out our guide on Google Business Profile SEO.

Infographic showing how positive reviews influence customer trust and enhance a business's online presence.

2. Google Alerts

Google Alerts is a free tool that lets business owners monitor mentions of their business or brand online.

With Google Alerts, you can set up alerts for your business name, keywords related to your industry, or even your competitors.

This allows you to stay on top of what’s being said about your business and industry online.

Using Google Alerts with other reputation management tools and strategies can help you stay ahead of the curve and build a positive online reputation for your local business.

Depiction of how Google alerts can be used for small business reputation management and digital marketing strategy

3. Review Sites

Online reviews for local businesses on sites like Yelp play a significant role in shaping a business’s reputation.

These platforms allow customers to leave reviews and ratings of your business, affecting your visibility in search results and perceptions of potential customers.

It’s essential to actively monitor your business’s reviews on these platforms and respond to feedback, especially when it comes to addressing a negative review, to demonstrate your commitment to providing excellent customer service and help improve your overall reputation across the platform.

In addition to monitoring reviews and responding to them, there are several strategies you can use to get your customers to write reviews.

This includes actively asking customers to leave a review, making it easy for them to do so by providing links to your business’s profiles on review sites and offering incentives like discounts or free products/services in exchange for a review.

Many businesses use reputation management software like ReputationStacker to automate their review management.

4. Social Media

Social media can be a powerful tool for managing your local business’s online reputation.

Sites like Facebook allow you to actively engage with customers, build a strong relationship with your audience, and address any concerns or questions they may have.

To effectively manage your online reputation on social media, it’s essential to monitor your accounts regularly and promptly and professionally respond to customer feedback. This means acknowledging positive feedback, addressing negative feedback, and taking steps to resolve any challenges that customers may be experiencing.

In addition to responding to customer feedback, you can also use social media to proactively build a positive online presence for your business.

Sharing updates about your products and services, showcasing customer testimonials, and highlighting community involvement are just some ways to demonstrate your commitment to providing excellent customer service and building a strong presence in your community.

Graphic showcasing how social media posts can shape a small business's online reputation and customer perception.

5. Supporting Local Causes

Supporting local causes can be an effective offline way for a local business to build a positive reputation and attract more customers.

By investing in their local community, businesses can demonstrate their commitment to social responsibility and build trust with customers. This can include sponsoring local events, partnering with local charities, or participating in community initiatives.

Additionally, supporting local causes can also help businesses to:

  • Increase their online visibility through social media and local press coverage

  • Build relationships with local influencers and thought leaders

  • Differentiate themselves from competitors and build a unique brand identity

  • Attract customers who are loyal to small businesses and willing to support them

By incorporating supporting local causes into their reputation management strategy, small businesses can build a strong online reputation and attract new customers who share their values.

This proactive approach not only enhances the business’s image but also fosters a sense of community and loyalty among customers.

Visual representation of tactics for engaging existing customers to encourage glowing reviews and feedback.

6. Industry-Specific Websites

Industry-specific sites can be helpful resources for managing your online reputation.

For healthcare facilities and organizations, industry-specific websites can make or break their reputation since patients rely on doctor review sites to research physicians, read and write reviews, and make appointments.

For other companies, industry-specific review sites allow customers to leave reviews and provide feedback on businesses in your specific industry. Whether it’s real estate, law, building construction, or any other industry, there’s a good chance that there’s an industry-specific review site that’s most important for your business.

By monitoring these sites and responding to reviews, you can improve your online reputation and convert potential customers who are already looking for the type of service that you provide.

Example of search results displaying a local business's reputation through recent reviews and ratings.

7. Online Message Boards

Online message boards, like Reddit, can be a valuable tool for managing your local business’s online reputation.

Prospective customers often turn to these platforms to gauge the credibility and reliability of a business.

Reddit and similar platforms allow users to discuss a wide range of topics and share their experiences with businesses, products, and services.

Monitoring online message boards related to your industry or niche can allow you to gain helpful insights into customer sentiment. Message boards can help business owners identify areas where their company is performing well and areas where there is room for improvement.

In addition to monitoring message boards, business owners can actively participate in these communities by responding to customer feedback and addressing any questions or concerns about their products or services.

Business owners must exercise caution when approaching online message boards, as these platforms can be unpredictable. Negative feedback can quickly spiral out of control if handled improperly. When engaging with customers on message boards, it’s critical to maintain a professional tone and avoid getting defensive or argumentative.

Checklist of effective strategies for generating more positive reviews from happy customers.

8. Your Business Website

Your business website is essential for establishing your online presence and managing your reputation.

Optimizing your website for search engines and providing valuable content to your target audience can attract more traffic and build trust with potential customers.

Some ways to get the most out of your business’s website include:

Including a Reviews or Testimonials Page 

Your website should feature a testimonials page showcasing positive customer reviews. Make it easy for customers to leave a review by including links to your business listings on review sites like Yelp, Google, and Facebook.

Creating High-Quality Content

Regularly posting high-quality content on your website can help establish your business as an authority in your industry or niche.

Consider creating blog posts, infographics, and videos that provide helpful information to your target audience.

Optimizing Your Website for Search Engines

Optimizing your website for search engines is a crucial aspect of small business online reputation management, as it can improve your online visibility and attract more traffic to your site.

Search engine optimization can positively impact your online reputation, as potential customers are more likely to trust businesses that appear at the top of search engine results pages.

Reviews and testimonials displayed on a business website to increase consumer trust and rank higher in search results

9. ReputationStacker

After you optimize your website and set up your profiles on review sites, you can make maintaining a positive online reputation easy by using automated reputation management software like ReputationStacker.

ReputationStacker is a powerful tool that can help small businesses automate the process of getting reviews and responding to them, in addition to gaining deep insights about your business that you otherwise wouldn’t have access to.

A computer monitor displays ReputationStacker review management software

Conclusion

Managing your local business’s reputation is essential for building customer trust and driving success.

By actively engaging with customers, addressing feedback—both positive and negative—and maintaining a strong online presence, you can improve your brand’s image and build long-term customer loyalty.

One effective way to streamline online reputation management is by using automated tools like ReputationStacker.

It simplifies online reputation management by helping businesses gather and manage reviews effortlessly. This proactive approach not only saves time but also helps ensure that your business maintains a positive reputation.

Embrace reputation management as a foundational element of your local marketing strategy, and leverage tools like ReputationStacker to strengthen your brand’s presence in your community.

Frequently Asked Questions About Online Reputation Management For Local Businesses

What is online reputation management?

Online reputation management involves monitoring and influencing how a business appears online, including managing online reviews, social media presence, and customer feedback.

How can I improve my business’s online reputation?

The easiest ways to improve reputation include encouraging customers to leave positive reviews, responding to negative feedback, and maintaining active social media profiles.

What are the main factors that affect the online reputation of my business?

The main factors that affect the online reputation of your business include the volume and quality of online reviews, social media interactions, customer surveys, and how the business is mentioned in news articles.

How can I find the best reputation management company?

You can find the best reputation management company for your business by reading client reviews, asking for referrals, and comparing pricing and services. Look for a company that understands the specific needs of businesses like yours.

What does hiring a reputation management consultant involve?

Hiring a reputation management consultant typically involves an assessment of your current online presence, developing a tailored reputation management strategy, and ongoing monitoring and support.

What is the cost of reputation management services?

Reputation management pricing varies based on the scope of services offered, from basic monitoring to comprehensive management strategies. Expect to pay anywhere from a few hundred to several thousand dollars monthly.

How can review sites impact my business?

Review sites like Google Reviews significantly influence customer perception, as they often appear in search results and can sway customers’ decisions.

How can I manage negative reviews effectively?

Respond promptly and professionally to negative reviews, acknowledge the issue, and offer solutions. This shows customers that you care about their experience.

What is a reputation management strategy?

A reputation management strategy is a plan that outlines how a business will monitor, influence, and respond to feedback and online mentions.

How does social media affect the reputation of my business?

Social media plays a crucial role in shaping public perception. Engaging with customers through posts and comments can help to build loyalty and improve your business’s image.

What role does review software play in reputation management?

Review software like ReputationStacker helps businesses track online reviews, manage feedback, and automate review requests, making it easier to maintain a positive online presence.

How can I encourage customers to leave positive reviews?

You can encourage reviews by asking satisfied customers directly, providing incentives, and following up with customer surveys after a purchase.

What are local business reviews, and why are they important?

Local business reviews are customer feedback specific to a geographical area. They enhance your visibility in local search results and can significantly impact customer trust.

How can I handle negative press about my business?

Address negative press directly, clarify any misinformation, and share positive content to help counteract the negative coverage.

What are some key metrics to monitor in reputation management?

Key metrics to track for reputation management include the number of positive vs. negative reviews, average rating across platforms, customer sentiment analysis, and social media engagement rates.

How can content marketing improve my business reputation?

Creating positive content that highlights customer success stories and community involvement can improve your brand image and customer perception.

How do I manage my business profiles across different platforms?

Regularly update and monitor your business profiles on review sites and social media to ensure accurate information and engage with customers effectively. Reputation management software like ReputationStacker can help with this.

How can community events help improve my local business reputation?

Participating in community events builds goodwill, fosters customer relationships, and generates positive press, all of which contribute to a stronger online reputation.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Ian Kirby has been working in digital marketing for over 15 years. Having worked both with and for digital marketing agencies and in-house with multiple companies, he has a specific interest and expertise in online reputation management, online reviews, and the implementation of business systems. Ian’s writing, videos, and interviews have garnered millions of reads, views, and listens.

+246%

reviews on

How To Get Google Reviews

+87%

reviews on

How to get more Yelp reviews

+173%

reviews on

Get Facebook Reviews For Business

The average ReputationStacker user triples their review count in the first 3 months.